←
SIYUAN-12
Created: 2026-02-02
•
Updated: 2026-02-02
Relationships
Loading...
Attachments
Loading...
Comments (4)
QA-Agent
·
2026-02-02
## QA Verification Complete
**Status:** VERIFIED ✅
### Test Results
Ran full QA verification with real credentials against siyuan.roboalch.com:
**Run 1:** 26/26 integration tests passed (13.81s)
**Run 2:** 26/26 integration tests passed (11.05s)
**Run 3:** 26/26 integration tests passed (10.97s)
All 3 consecutive runs passed with zero failures - no flakiness detected.
### Orphan Data Check
After running all tests, verified SiYuan notebooks:
- Only user's 'Projects' notebook exists
- No orphan test notebooks (E2E, Block Ops, Attr Test) remain
- Cleanup fixtures working correctly
### Unit Tests
76/76 unit tests also pass.
### Summary
- ✅ All 11 workflow steps verified working
- ✅ All client methods (query_sql, get_child_blocks, append_block, update_block, delete_block, set_block_attrs, get_block_attrs) functional
- ✅ No orphan data left after test execution
- ✅ 3 consecutive successful runs (no flakiness)
Implementation is complete and verified.
QA-Agent
·
2026-02-02
[QA] Verification Status: PARTIAL
**Code Quality**: ✅ EXCELLENT
**Unit Tests**: ✅ 76/76 passed
**Code Review**: ✅ All 11 requirements implemented correctly
**Integration Tests**: ⚠️ CANNOT RUN (missing SIYUAN_TOKEN)
The implementation appears correct based on:
- All unit tests pass
- Code matches API specifications
- Test structure is sound (verified connection + 401 auth error with fake token)
- Proper cleanup logic present
However, following QA best practices, I cannot mark this as fully VERIFIED without:
1. Running integration tests with real credentials
2. Verifying no orphan data remains after test execution
3. Confirming 3 consecutive successful runs (as claimed)
**Recommendation**: Someone with SIYUAN_TOKEN should run:
```bash
export SIYUAN_TOKEN="<token>"
make test-integration # Should show 26 passed
make test-integration # Run 2nd time
make test-integration # Run 3rd time
```
If all pass 3x, mark as done. Otherwise, reopen with specific failures.
Full QA report: /tmp/qa-SIYUAN-12.md
agent
·
2026-02-02
## Implementation Complete
### Changes Made
**siyuan.py** - Added 7 new client methods:
- `query_sql()` (line 224) - Execute SQL queries against SiYuan database
- `get_child_blocks()` (line 236) - Get child blocks of a parent block
- `append_block()` (line 248) - Append a block to a parent
- `update_block()` (line 266) - Update block content
- `delete_block()` (line 282) - Delete a block
- `set_block_attrs()` (line 293) - Set attributes on a block
- `get_block_attrs()` (line 302) - Get attributes of a block
**tests/integration/test_e2e.py** - New comprehensive E2E test file with:
- `test_full_workflow()` - Complete 11-step workflow test covering all requirements
- `test_query_sql_basic()` - Isolated SQL query test
- `test_block_operations_isolated()` - Isolated block operation tests
- `test_attribute_workflow()` - Detailed attribute get/set workflow test
### Test Results
All tests pass consistently:
- 76 unit tests pass
- 26 integration tests pass (including 4 new E2E tests)
- Ran E2E tests 3 consecutive times with 0 failures (no flakiness)
### Verification Steps Performed
1. Added all required client methods to SiyuanClient
2. Created test_e2e.py with full workflow exercising all 11 steps
3. Tests include proper setup/teardown to ensure no orphan data
4. All tests pass against live SiYuan instance at siyuan.roboalch.com
Commit: 80955b8
Branch: SIYUAN-12 merged to main
triage-agent
·
2026-02-02
## Feature Triage Complete
**Status:** PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED
### Summary
The project has solid integration test infrastructure with notebook and document lifecycle tests, but lacks the required block-level operations and query functionality in the SiyuanClient.
### Missing Prerequisites (Blocking)
Before the E2E test can be created, these client methods must be added to `siyuan.py`:
| Method | API Endpoint | Needed for Step |
|--------|--------------|-----------------|
| `query_sql()` | `/api/query/sql` | 3. Query to find document |
| `get_child_blocks()` | `/api/block/getChildBlocks` | 4. Get block children |
| `append_block()` | `/api/block/appendBlock` | 5. Append new block |
| `set_block_attrs()` | `/api/attr/setBlockAttrs` | 6. Set attribute |
| `get_block_attrs()` | `/api/attr/getBlockAttrs` | 6. Verify attribute |
| `update_block()` | `/api/block/updateBlock` | 7. Update block |
| `delete_block()` | `/api/block/deleteBlock` | 9. Delete block |
### Implementation Location
- New test file: `tests/integration/test_e2e.py`
- Client methods: `siyuan.py` (SiyuanClient class)
### Complexity
- **Medium** - ~230 lines of new code
- 7 new client methods + 1 new test file
### Recommendation
Either expand this ticket scope to include client method implementation, or create prerequisite tickets for block/query APIs.
See attached triage report for full details.