SIYUAN-28 - trckr

← SIYUAN-28

feature

Created: 2026-02-02 • Updated: 2026-02-03

Relationships Loading...

## Overview
Add AI/ChatGPT integration commands using undocumented SiYuan API.

**Note**: These commands require AI to be configured in SiYuan settings (Settings > AI).

## New Commands

```bash
siyuan ai chat "What is this document about?"
siyuan ai chat "Summarize this" --context BLOCK_ID
siyuan ai chat "Translate to Spanish" --context BLOCK_ID

siyuan ai action summarize BLOCK_ID
siyuan ai action translate BLOCK_ID --lang Spanish
siyuan ai action explain BLOCK_ID
```

## API Endpoints
- `/api/ai/chatGPT` - Send message to AI (params: msg, context?)
- `/api/ai/chatGPTWithAction` - AI with predefined action (params: action, ids, etc.)

## Implementation
1. Add 2 client methods to SiyuanClient
2. Add handler functions for chat and action
3. Create `ai` CLI group with `chat` and `action` subcommands
4. Create `tests/test_ai.py`
5. Create `tests/integration/test_ai_live.py`
6. Update README

## Error Handling
- Clear error message if AI is not configured
- Timeout handling for slow AI responses (increase default timeout)
- Show helpful message if API returns empty response

## Output Format (chat)
```
AI Response:

This document appears to be about API integration patterns. 
The main topics covered include:
- REST endpoint design
- Authentication methods
- Error handling

---
Model: gpt-4
Tokens: 150
```

## Output Format (action)
```
Action: summarize
Block: 20240101-abcdefg

Summary:
This block describes the implementation of a sorting algorithm
using the divide-and-conquer approach...
```

## QA Verification

### Pass Criteria
1. `siyuan ai --help` shows available subcommands
2. `siyuan ai chat "hello"` returns AI response (if configured)
3. `siyuan ai chat --context BLOCK_ID` includes block content in context
4. Clear error message when AI is not configured
5. All tests pass (unit tests should mock AI responses)

### Fail Criteria
- Commands hang without timeout
- Unclear error messages
- Context not properly passed to AI
- Test failures

Pull Requests (comma-separated URLs)

Attachments

Comments (3)

QA-Agent · 2026-02-03

# QA Report: SIYUAN-28 - AI Integration Commands **Date:** 2026-02-03 **QA Engineer:** Code Verification Agent **Issue:** SIYUAN-28 - AI Integration Commands **Status:** ✅ VERIFIED --- ## Executive Summary The AI integration feature has been successfully implemented and verified. All requirements from the issue specification have been met, with comprehensive test coverage (30 unit tests + 18 integration tests) and clear documentation. The implementation follows project standards and includes proper error handling with helpful user messages. --- ## Verification Results ### 1. Implementation Review ✅ **Client Methods (siyuan.py:1086-1177)** - ✅ `_request_ai()`: Extended timeout helper (120s) for AI operations - ✅ `ai_chat(msg, context)`: Sends messages with optional block context - ✅ `ai_action(action, ids, lang)`: Executes predefined AI actions - ✅ Proper error handling with helpful messages when AI not configured - ✅ Graceful handling of various response formats (dict, string, null) **Handler Functions (siyuan.py:2716-2797)** - ✅ `handle_ai_chat()`: Fetches block content when context requested - ✅ `handle_ai_action()`: Processes action results with proper formatting - ✅ Text output includes metadata (model, tokens) when available - ✅ JSON/YAML output preserves full response structure **CLI Commands (siyuan.py:4257-4345)** - ✅ `siyuan ai` group with clear docstrings - ✅ `siyuan ai chat MSG [--context/-c BLOCK_ID]` - ✅ `siyuan ai action ACTION BLOCK_IDS... [--lang/-l LANG]` - ✅ Action choices properly restricted to 7 valid values - ✅ Format override support via `--format` option ### 2. Test Coverage ✅ **Unit Tests (tests/test_ai.py)** - ✅ 30 test cases covering all functionality - ✅ Tests for both client methods and CLI commands - ✅ Error handling tests (API errors, missing args, empty responses) - ✅ Various response format tests (dict, string, null) - ✅ Context and language parameter tests - ✅ Output format tests (text, JSON, YAML) **Integration Tests (tests/integration/test_ai_live.py)** - ✅ 18 integration test cases - ✅ Tests skip gracefully when AI not configured - ✅ Real API endpoint testing (when available) - ✅ Context fetching integration tests **Test Execution:** ``` 488 passed, 273 deselected in 1.72s ``` All tests pass successfully. ### 3. Help Documentation ✅ **`siyuan ai --help`:** ``` AI/ChatGPT integration commands. These commands require AI to be configured in SiYuan Settings > AI. Commands: action Execute a predefined AI action on blocks. chat Send a message to the AI assistant. ``` ✅ Clear, informative help text **`siyuan ai chat --help`:** - ✅ Shows correct usage with MSG argument - ✅ Documents --context/-c option - ✅ Includes 3 helpful examples - ✅ Shows format override option **`siyuan ai action --help`:** - ✅ Shows action choices clearly - ✅ Documents all 7 available actions with descriptions - ✅ Shows --lang/-l option for translation - ✅ Includes helpful examples ### 4. README Documentation ✅ **README.md changes:** - ✅ New "AI Commands" section added - ✅ Chat examples with context usage - ✅ Action examples with language option - ✅ Sample output formats shown - ✅ Action reference table with descriptions - ✅ Clear note about AI configuration requirement ### 5. Error Handling ✅ **Verified Error Scenarios:** - ✅ Clear error when AI not configured: "AI error: {msg}. Please ensure AI is configured in SiYuan Settings > AI." - ✅ Timeout increased to 120s for slow AI responses - ✅ Empty response handling: "AI returned an empty response." - ✅ Context block fetch failures handled gracefully - ✅ Missing required arguments show proper CLI errors ### 6. QA Pass Criteria ✅ From issue specification: 1. ✅ `siyuan ai --help` shows available subcommands - **Result:** Shows `chat` and `action` subcommands with descriptions 2. ✅ `siyuan ai chat "hello"` returns AI response (if configured) - **Result:** Properly formatted with metadata, handles unconfigured case 3. ✅ `siyuan ai chat --context BLOCK_ID` includes block content in context - **Result:** Fetches block content via `get_block_kramdown()` first 4. ✅ Clear error message when AI is not configured - **Result:** Helpful message directs user to SiYuan Settings > AI 5. ✅ All tests pass (unit tests should mock AI responses) - **Result:** 488 tests pass, mocking properly implemented --- ## Code Quality Assessment ### Strengths 1. **Comprehensive Testing:** 48 test cases (30 unit + 18 integration) cover happy paths, edge cases, and error scenarios 2. **Proper Timeout Handling:** 120s timeout for AI operations prevents premature timeouts 3. **Helpful Error Messages:** AI-specific errors detected and enhanced with configuration guidance 4. **Flexible Response Handling:** Handles dict, string, and null responses gracefully 5. **Documentation:** Excellent README examples and inline docstrings 6. **Integration Pattern:** Follows existing codebase patterns consistently ### Adherence to Standards - ✅ Single-module design maintained (all in siyuan.py) - ✅ Click command structure matches existing commands - ✅ Output formatting consistent with other commands - ✅ Test structure mirrors existing test files - ✅ Error handling via `cli_error()` like other commands --- ## Manual Verification Checklist ### Command Help - ✅ `siyuan ai --help` displays correctly - ✅ `siyuan ai chat --help` shows examples - ✅ `siyuan ai action --help` lists all actions ### Error Cases - ✅ Missing token shows appropriate error - ✅ Missing required arguments show usage - ✅ API errors display helpful messages ### Code Review - ✅ No security vulnerabilities identified - ✅ No hardcoded credentials or tokens - ✅ Proper HTTP timeout handling - ✅ Safe block content fetching --- ## Potential Concerns (None Found) No blocking issues identified. The implementation is production-ready. --- ## Recommendations **None required.** The implementation exceeds expectations with: - Excellent test coverage (48 tests) - Clear documentation and examples - Robust error handling - Proper timeout management --- ## Final Verdict **✅ QA PASSED** The implementation fully satisfies all requirements from SIYUAN-28: - All client methods implemented correctly - Handler functions work as specified - CLI commands with proper help text - Comprehensive test suite (unit + integration) - README updated with examples - Error handling with helpful messages - Timeout handling for slow AI responses **Recommendation:** Mark issue as DONE and merge to main. --- ## Test Evidence **Test Execution:** ``` pytest tests/ -v -m "not integration" ============================= test session starts ============================== collected 761 items / 273 deselected / 488 selected tests/test_ai.py::TestSiyuanClientAI::test_ai_chat_basic PASSED [ 0%] tests/test_ai.py::TestSiyuanClientAI::test_ai_chat_with_context PASSED [ 0%] [... 486 more tests ...] ===================== 488 passed, 273 deselected in 1.72s ====================== ``` **Help Output Verified:** - AI command group help displays correctly - Chat subcommand help includes examples - Action subcommand help lists all 7 actions with descriptions **Code Structure:** - Client methods: Lines 1086-1177 in siyuan.py - Handlers: Lines 2716-2797 in siyuan.py - CLI: Lines 4257-4345 in siyuan.py - Unit tests: tests/test_ai.py (488 lines, 30 tests) - Integration tests: tests/integration/test_ai_live.py (300 lines, 18 tests) - Documentation: README.md updated with 76 new lines --- **Verified by:** Code Verification QA Agent **Date:** 2026-02-03T02:50:00Z

agent · 2026-02-03

## Implementation Complete ### Changes Made **Client Methods (siyuan.py:1084-1177):** - `_request_ai()`: Extended timeout (120s) helper for AI API calls - `ai_chat(msg, context)`: Send messages to AI with optional block context - `ai_action(action, ids, lang)`: Execute predefined AI actions **Handler Functions (siyuan.py:2716-2797):** - `handle_ai_chat()`: Fetches block content for context, formats output - `handle_ai_action()`: Processes action results, formats output **CLI Commands (siyuan.py:4257-4345):** - `siyuan ai` group with helpful docstrings - `siyuan ai chat MSG [--context/-c BLOCK_ID]` - `siyuan ai action ACTION BLOCK_IDS... [--lang/-l LANG]` **Tests:** - `tests/test_ai.py`: 30 unit tests with mocked HTTP - `tests/integration/test_ai_live.py`: Integration tests that skip when AI not configured **README.md:** Added AI Commands section with examples and action reference table ### Verification - All 488 unit tests pass - `siyuan ai --help` shows both subcommands - `siyuan ai chat --help` and `siyuan ai action --help` show correct usage - Error handling tested for AI-not-configured scenarios ### Files Changed - siyuan.py (+277 lines) - README.md (+76 lines) - tests/test_ai.py (new, 488 lines) - tests/integration/test_ai_live.py (new, 300 lines) Merged to main and pushed.

triage-agent · 2026-02-03

## Feature Triage Complete **Status:** NOT IMPLEMENTED - Feature does not exist in siyuan-cli **Summary:** - SiYuan has AI endpoints (`/api/ai/chatGPT` and `/api/ai/chatGPTWithAction`) confirmed via kernel source - No AI functionality currently exists in siyuan-cli - Implementation requires adding client methods, handlers, and CLI commands to siyuan.py - Tests need to gracefully handle cases where AI is not configured **Implementation Location:** - Client methods: `siyuan.py` around line ~1085 - Handlers: `siyuan.py` around line ~2600 - CLI commands: `siyuan.py` around line ~4060 - New test files: `tests/test_ai.py` and `tests/integration/test_ai_live.py` **Complexity:** Medium **Key Considerations:** - Need longer timeout (60s+) for AI requests - Must handle "AI not configured" error gracefully - Context feature requires fetching block content first - Integration tests should skip if AI not configured See attached triage report for full details.